Chapter 5 - What Renee Knew

"Mr. Briggs." Renee Castillo's voice was measured. Not surprised in the least. "I wondered when someone would call me."
I sat in my car, engine off, the envelope on the passenger seat.
"You know about Dale Kessler's motion," I said.
"I filed the original termination. Of course I know." A pause. "How's Eli?"
The question caught me off guard.
"He's — he's holding on. He spoke last night. First time ever."
Silence on her end.
"What did he say?"
"One word. He said don't."
Another silence, longer this time. When she spoke again, something had shifted underneath her professional tone.
"Mr. Briggs, I need to ask you something directly. Did Kessler say anything else at your door last night? Beyond identifying himself?"
"He said the agency had been losing his calls and letters. Said his attorney had already filed."
"That's all?"
"He said he had paperwork."
"He doesn't," she said flatly. "He has a motion. There's a difference. A motion is a request. No judge has agreed to hear it yet."
"But one might."
"One might," she agreed. "Which is why I want to meet with you in person. Today, if possible."
I checked my watch. "I told Eli I'd be back before lunch."
"This afternoon, then. My office. Three o'clock."
I agreed and hung up. On the drive home, I found Eli at the kitchen table with Peggy, working on a puzzle. He looked up when I walked in.
I held up three fingers.
He looked at them, then back at me, and gave a single nod.
Peggy quietly gathered her things. At the door, she touched my arm. "He's a good boy, Walter."
"I know," I said.
After she left, Eli and I ate lunch — soup from a can, bread I'd baked the day before. He ate carefully, the way he always did, like part of him still wasn't sure the meals would keep coming.
I watched him eat and thought about Dale Kessler's voice through the door. Low. Certain. The voice of a man who had rehearsed every word.
After lunch, Eli went to his room. I knocked on the frame.
"I've got one more errand this afternoon," I said. "Peggy's coming back to sit with you. That all right?"
He looked at me for a moment. Then he picked up a pencil, wrote something on the corner of a page, and held it up.
Is he coming back?
My chest tightened.
"I don't know," I said, because I wasn't going to lie to him. "But I'm working on making sure you're safe. That's exactly what this errand is about."
He looked down at the paper, set the pencil aside, and turned back to his drawing. I took that as permission.
Renee's office sat on the fourth floor of a downtown building, small and orderly, books stacked with precision. She was younger than her voice suggested — mid-forties, dark hair, reading glasses shoved up on her head.
She slid a document across the desk before I'd fully sat down.
"Dale Kessler's original termination," she said. "Read the third paragraph."
I read it. Then I read it again.
"He surrendered his rights in exchange for dropped charges," I said slowly.
"Correct."
"What charges?"
She held my eyes. "The welfare check that got Eli removed from the home. Whatever followed it."
"The article I found said a child was removed. It didn't say why."
"It wouldn't have. Eli was four. Details were sealed." She folded her hands. "Mr. Briggs, Dale Kessler didn't give up his parental rights because he loved his son and thought it was best for him. He gave them up to avoid prosecution. The agreement was made with legal counsel on both sides, documented and signed."
"Then how is he filing a motion now?"
"He found an attorney willing to argue duress — that the agreement was made under coercion." She paused. "It's a weak argument. But weak arguments still require answers. And Kessler is counting on one thing."
"What?"
"That you don't know what I just told you." She tapped the document. "And that Eli can't tell you himself."
The room went very quiet.
"He knows Eli doesn't speak," I said.
"He's always known." Her voice went flat. "That's not a coincidence, Mr. Briggs. That's a calculation."
I sat with that a moment. "What do I do?"
"You let me file a response. You get Eli assessed by a court-approved child psychologist — someone whose testimony will actually carry weight. And you don't open your door to Dale Kessler again. Under any circumstances."
"And if a judge grants the hearing?"
Renee picked up her pen. "Then we show them everything," she said. "And Dale Kessler will wish he'd stayed quiet."
She started writing. I sat there thinking about a seven-year-old boy who checked every lock in the house each night, who slept with the light on, who hadn't spoken a single word in three years — until a stranger knocked on a door.
One word.
May you like
Don't.
He'd known. Even before I did, he'd known exactly what that knock meant.