Chapter 1 - The Face That Didn't Belong
The first time I looked at my newborn daughter, I felt two things at once.
Love. And confusion.
Willow was beautiful, but she looked nothing like me or my wife, Diane. She had thick black hair, a broad little nose, heavy-lidded dark eyes — features that didn't resemble either of us at all. Diane has blonde hair, light eyes, a narrow nose, high cheekbones, a delicate jaw. I'm fair-haired and blue-eyed. Put the three of us side by side, and Willow looked like she belonged to a completely different family.
I hated myself for noticing.
At first I blamed newborn weirdness. Babies change. Hair falls out. Eye color shifts. Genetics can pull traits from grandparents nobody's thought about in decades.
Then our relatives started noticing too.
My mother stared into the bassinet and asked, "Where did all that dark hair come from?"
Diane's sister laughed awkwardly. "She really doesn't look like either of you."
Diane's whole expression changed. "She's four days old," she snapped. "Can everyone stop analyzing her face?"
The room went silent. That reaction stayed with me.
I told myself she was exhausted — she'd just given birth, sleeping in two-hour stretches, her body wrecked, and people picking apart our daughter's face probably felt invasive to her. Still, something about it bothered me.
Over the next two weeks, Willow's features only grew more pronounced, and every time someone mentioned them, Diane got defensive. If I casually asked whether anyone on her side had looked similar as a baby, I got nothing solid back. "Maybe my grandmother." "Genetics are strange." "She'll change."
I tried to accept that. But I started noticing something else too — Diane never once seemed surprised by Willow's appearance. Everyone else was. I was. She wasn't.
One night, with Willow asleep between us in her bassinet, I finally asked, "Did you expect her to have dark hair?"
Diane kept her eyes on the ceiling. "No."
"You don't seem surprised."
"I'm tired, Nathan."
"That's not what I asked."
She turned toward me. "What exactly are you asking?"
I immediately regretted opening my mouth. "I don't know."
"Then figure it out before you ask me." She rolled over.
I lay awake another hour. The thought I'd been trying desperately not to have had already arrived on its own.
May you like
What if Willow wasn't mine?
I felt disgusting even thinking it. Diane and I had been together eight years, married five. I'd never once caught her lying about another man. She'd never disappeared unexpectedly or guarded her phone. There was no evidence of an affair anywhere. There was only our daughter's face — and Diane's strange refusal to talk about it.
